Hawthorne, Salem, and the Sea


By
Joseph Flibbert


A few years ago, I was having lunch with a Japanese scholar who had a special interest in Nathaniel Hawthorne and who was visiting Salem for the first time. His early impressions of the city, he told me, were quite different from those he anticipated from descriptions of Salem in Hawthorne's works. Having recently visited the National Maritime Historic Site and the Peabody Museum, he was surprised to learn how prominent a role the sea played in the town Hawthorne was born in in 1804. The Salem of Hawthorne's imagination, he noted, was bordered more by the forest than the sea. The real Salem of Hawthorne's youth, he went on, was dominated by the sea. Having an interest in both sea literature and Hawthorne, I've puzzled over the virtual absence of the sea in Hawthorne's works myself. Was he by nature an inland soul, or were there other factors at work?
He was born into a sea-going family. His father, his uncle, and his grandfather were all ships' masters. During his early years Salem was still one of the busiest seaports in America. He lived most of that period on Herbert St., just a stone's throw from the busy wharves, and, as a sensitive and impressionable child, he must have absorbed many of the exotic sights, sounds, and smells of those ships and cargoes, seamen and merchants.
Altogether, Hawthorne spent more than half his 60 years here in Salem and, if you count his residencies in other sea-coast towns and cities in America and in England, about two-thirds of his life by the sea. One of the major reasons why he wanted to leave the beautiful views of the Tanglewood Bowl in Lenox in 1851, where he and his family had been living for the past sixteen months, was to return to a residence by the sea, whose air and climate seemed more agreeable to his wife, Sophia's health and, although they eventually settled in Concord, they had considered a house on Marblehead Neck.
Had he gone before the mast as a youth (a prospect he teased his mother about as a boy), perhaps we would have had some tales of the sea from him. By 1853--the year of his first ocean crossing--he had already penned his roughly 100 tales and sketches and had published four of the five romances he was to complete. Up to that point in his life, and beyond, most of his experience with ships had been with vessels in port, another curious feature of this topic.
Hawthorne considered himself an author. But because writing didn't pay very well, he was occasionally forced to resort to working at other jobs. I say "occasionally" because he avoided it as often as he could. It took him more than ten years to get his first job after college--as an editor of a magazine--and it lasted just the first six months of 1836 before he quit. He also remained less than six months at Brook Farm in 1841, where he spent most of his time shoveling cow dung. Altogether, Hawthorne worked at jobs other than writing tales for eleven of the thirty-nine years he lived after graduating from college. But the other ten years of work experience placed him in an intimate, usually daily contact with maritime activities and issues.
His first appointment was to the prosaic position of measurer of salt and coal at the Boston Custom House, a job he held for about two years from 1839 to 1841. When a ship was in port, he rose at 4:00 a.m. to be on the docks--usually Boston's Long Wharf--by sunrise, to supervise the shoveling, measuring, and unloading of the ship's cargo, sometimes moving back and forth between two vessels, until sunset. By the end of the day, Hawthorne would often find himself smeared from head to foot with what he called "the sable stains of my profession--stains which I share in common with chimney-sweepers." While this had its drawbacks, it also sometimes worked to his advantage. Not being a party animal, on more than one occasion he pointed to his "coal-begrimed visage and salt-befrosted locks" as an excuse for turning down a dinner invitation. Clearly, he found very little stimulation in the job. In one letter to Sophia, he observed, "Everything that I do here might be better done by a machine. I am a machine, and am surrounded by hundreds of similar machines." The days were monotonous, bitterly cold during the winter and oppressively hot during the summer. More to the point, he bemoaned the fact that his responsibilities "entirely break me up as a literary man." Hawthorne wrote virtually nothing during this period, except letters and entries in his notebooks. And that would be the pattern for his other jobs. In reference to those notebooks, during the twenty-five years in which he kept a journal, Hawthorne regularly used his entries to record material for future use in his stories, often recording his experiences and commenting on how they might be used fictionally. While the routines of his work dockside may have been tediously repetitive, the characters he encountered were as varied as the ports they came from. The seamen and the dock workers were constantly exchanging stories and, sometimes, blows. There was an intense and often tempestuous undercurrent of life beneath the grime and grind of the day's unloadings that Hawthorne seems to have been strangely unresponsive to. One would expect that a writer keeping a journal filled with notes on interesting characters he had met would have sketched the rogues' gallery of types he came in contact with, and recorded the yarns spun during breaks in the work day. But Hawthorne appears not to have seen much in the line of fictional possibilities there, for--aside from a few disparaging comments in his letters on the "thick-pated, stubborn, contentious men" he worked with-- there are few detailed descriptions of character types and no detailed accounts of unusual experiences. Perhaps the coal dust dropped a black veil over the star dust. In one of the journals he kept during this period, there are about three dozen brief entries on ideas for stories. None of them allude to maritime activity. In the other journal, there is one description of an old salt, summaries of a few anecdotes related at the Custom House by a friend, and brief descriptions of the hold of a schooner, an old man fishing on Long Wharf, the names of schooners, the arrival of factory girls from England, and a young sailor. With possibly the exception of the description of the old sailor, none of these seem to have been recorded for future use in his tales and, to my knowledge, none appear in his later fiction. In a letter to Sophia during this period, he comments on the incongruity of observing a butterfly amidst "the brick stores, stone piers, black ships, and the bustle of the toilsome men." But it is precisely this kind of incongruity that Hawthorne's imagination, when active, seized upon. A few years later, he would use a butterfly as a symbol of artistic aspiration in one of his tales. But here it only seemed out of place. His fancy, said in another letter to have been "rendered so torpid by my ungenial way of life," could not, under blunted circumstances, see the intriguing possibilities in this or, apparently, in other experiences of the period. The next job that brought him into contact with the sea was his appointment as surveyor of the port of Salem, a position he held for about three years from 1846 to 1849. For this assignment, he substituted a desk for the docks, but the desk gave him a crow's nest perch above most of the activity on those docks. More importantly, it placed him within earshot of his subordinates, mostly former seamen who lounged in the hallway next to his office regaling one another with inflated accounts of their sea adventures. Only one of those accounts appears in the notebooks. And, except for a description of a trip he took with his boss's son, there are no other references in them to his Salem Custom House experience. The only entry during this period that suggested a story of the sea focuses on survivorsa of a sea wreck casting lots to decide who will be killed for dinner! Hawthorne's letters during this period are almost as silent on his duties as are the notebooks. He occasionally complains about something like a malfunctioning hydrometer, more often about a non-functioning inspector who fails to show up for work, or a captain trying to hide contraband, but for the most part, he was not paying any more attention to the job than it required and than was necessary for him to collect his fees. Instead, he seems to have been into watching with fascination the developmemt of the two children he then had, Una and Julian, whose antics and verbal whims were faithfully and abundantly recorded in his journals, as if he were the scribe of two diminutive sages. An example follows: Julian--"Mamma, why is not dinner supper?" Mamma--"Why is not a chair a table?" Julian--"Because it's a teapot." Only a proud, and maybe a slightly prejudiced parent, could see wisdom enough in that reply to record it for posterity. But that appears to be where Hawthorne was at this point in his life. Instead of turning over the yarns of his fellow workers for possible story plots, he was playing with his children, at least until two crises--his dismissal from the Custom House post and the death of his mother--would jolt him back to brooding over the darker world of his fiction. But then, he would fix his attention on the forest-dominated Boston of the seventeenth century, and on a certain scarlet letter. The third and last work experience that brought him in contact with maritime activity was his appointment as consul to Liverpool, his financial reward for having written the campaign biography for his friend, Franklin Pierce's successful run for the presidency. This post, which he held from August, 1853 through October of 1857, was the most lucrative in the American diplomatic service and would make him financially secure for the first time in his life, and for the rest of it. Liverpool was one of the most active ports in the world. In the year before Hawthorne arrived, about a thousand ships left its docks for the United States alone. As Consul, his major contacts were with ship's captains and seamen--signing documents for cargo processed through his office, shipping and discharging seamen, settling the estate of seamen who died in his jurisdiction, administering oaths, taking depositions from abused seamen, preparing powers of attorney, valuing goods--all of which activities he received a fee for. In the more than four years that he held the post, he sent about a hundred dispatches to the State Department, commenting--sometimes in considerable detail--on everything from shipwrecks and trade with England, to cruelty toward seamen. He gave advice, most of it ignored, on how to improve the merchant marine by establishing training centers, on ways to gain advantage over England on matters of trade, on laws that needed to be established to regulate the relationship between the officers and the crews of American merchant vessels. He was particularly disturbed by conflicts between seamen and captains, as evidenced by the lengthy comments in his notebooks on the frustrations he experienced in trying to mediate them. In fact, the notebooks and letters of this period contain a great deal of commentary on all the challenges and sources of frustration of his consular duties. Hawthorne was intensely and competently involved in the administration of his duties as consul, duties that invariably had a connection to the sea. But again, he wrote no fiction during this period, and no fiction he would later write would be inspired by these experiences, at least not those that involved maritime activity. Hawthorne's friendships suggest another dimension of his life that might have prompted him to write about the sea. One of his closest friends, Horatio Bridge, had been a college classmate and became one of the strongest supporters of both Hawthorne's career as an author and his political appointments. Bridge pursued a career in the American navy and periodically found himself on cruises lasting up to three years. When he was ashore, they took every occasion they could to visit one another. Hawthorne spent about six weeks at the Bridge family home in Augusta, Maine in 1837, and about two weeks visiting him with Sophia and Una in tow at the Portsmouth Naval Yard in 1845, where Bridge was temporarily stationed. No doubt, the conversations must have turned frequently to Bridge's experiences at sea. Hawthorne's devotion to his friend is suggested by Hawthorne's consent to edit a journal Bridge kept on his experiences at sea and in port on a cruise along the African coast. The book was published with Hawthorne's name on the title page in 1945. We don't know how many changes he made because the manuscript has not survived, but one can see the stamp of Hawthorne's graceful style on every page. This is, you might say, the closest he came to writing about the sea but in the capacity of a ghost writer for Bridge. Another college acquaintance and close personal friend is Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, easily the most popular poet writing in the English language during that period. Hawthorne and Longfellow maintained a regular correspondence from the mid 1830s to Hawthorne's death in 1864 and got together in Boston and Cambridge over dinner and champagne to discuss their various literary projects. Like Hawthorne, Longfellow grew up in a busy seaport town, Portland, Maine. Unlike Hawthorne, Longfellow's imagination was receptive to those early-life influences and the sea became one of the most prominent motifs in his writing. He uses it in ballads recalling historical events like "The Wreck of the Hesperus," in lyrics meditating on the mysterious patterns of life like "The Tide Rises, the Tide Falls," and in the longer narrative poems Americanizing the materials of Old World legend, as in the Norse sagas of Tales of a Wayside Inn. Longfellow titled one of his best-known collections of poems, first published in 1849, The Seaside and the Fireside. I'll return to Longfellow in a moment, but first I'd like to mention one other Hawthorne friendship. On August 5, 1850, shortly after moving to Lenox in western Massachusetts, Hawthorne took part in a picnic with a group of revellers who, among other things, ended up drinking champagne on the slope of Monument Mountain in the midst of a thunderstorm. There he met for the first time a young author who had launched what seemed like a promising career with five books published in the previous four years. That young author was Herman Melville. For the next sixteen months, they would be neighbors and would become close friends, exchanging visits between Pittsfield and Lenox, and spending hours in the fields and woods and, in cooler weather, in Melville's barn, smoking cigars, drinking port or brandy, and discussing futurity, eternity, and all things visible and invisible. Melville, of course, had extensive experience with the sea, having shipped first on a merchant vessel to Liverpool, then on whaling voyages to the South Seas, and finally on an American man-of-war. Altogether, Melville's experience as a seaman lasted about four and a half years and all five of those first books were narratives of the sea. Hawthorne had written an appreciative review of Melville's first book, Typee, and was acquainted with his later efforts. About the time they met, Melville wrote a complimentary essay on Hawthorne's collection of tales called Mosses From an Old Manse. The book Melville was working on when they met was Moby-Dick. Hawthorne had just begun to write The House of the Seven Gables. We find ourselves, therefore, at one of the most dramatic junctures in American literary history, with two of our most notable authors, at the height of their creative powers. These kindred spirits were standing at a common axis, around which their fancies would rotate from their shared concern with what Melville called the "great power of blackness" he saw in Hawthorne's works, fashioning their respective masterpieces.
Scholars have identified many of the influences these two authors had on one another, not only in the works they were currently composing, but in their later fiction as well. While both Hawthorne and Melville have suggested that their discussions often took a philosophical turn, there must also have been many occasions when Melville filled up the silences with anecdotes of his years at sea. These accounts may have prompted in Hawthorne a recollection of his adolescent thoughts about going to sea. But they don't seem to have inspired him to write about it.
In Salem, we like to think that Hawthorne's model for the structure he makes the central symbol of The House of the Seven Gables is the historic house on Turner Street, which took its name from the title of Hawthorne's romance. There is, of course, much to support that claim, including Hawthorne's association with the house, his discovery of the title of his book in a conversation on the house, and his description of features of his fictional abode consistent with features of the Turner Street house. However one omission in his description would be negligible under most circumstances but resonates with significance, given the actual location of the house. It is a curious but intriguing fact that Hawthorne never mentions a sea-side location for his fictional house.
It is particularly curious, given the kind of writer Hawthorne was, and given the uses to which the imagery of the sea were being put by friends and fellow authors like Longfellow and Melville. In Longfellow's "The Tide Rises," the sea's rhythmic surges and withdrawals become a metaphor for the pattern of human life, suggesting an element of permanence amidst the comings and passings of individual lives. In his poem called "Seaweed," the sea represents the inspirations and frustrations of human creativity. In another poem called "Ultima Thule," the search for truth is symbolized by a voyage to a remote place. As for Melville, in the past seventy years, critics have identified more symbolism in Moby-Dick than perhaps in any other book ever written.
My point here is that Longfellow and Melville saw imaginative possibilities in the subject of the sea that they explore in a symbolic vein. And they were not the only ones to do so at that time. Edgar Allan Poe, Henry David Thoreau, Walt Whitman, and Emily Dickinson all produced literature with a sea motif rich in suggestive and symbolic associations. Despite the fact that she may have only glimpsed the sea once or twice on the few occasions she left Amherst, Dickinson wrote more than one hundred poems with sea images in them.
These authors were responding to both historical influences and primeval impulses. Historically, America was, during this period, a maritime nation, with the vast majority of its population located along its eastern coast, with a substantial part of that population engaged directly or indirectly in its considerable world-wide mercantile activity. The immigration population booms that would shift the center of the country's activity to mills and factories was just beginning. And the massive shift of the population westward to the territories would not achieve momentum until after the Civil War. America was sea-situated, and sea conscious. It is not surprising, therefore, that the sea is a prominent subject in the works of most authors during this period.
But there is that other influence, less easy to identify but ultimately more profound. It is what the poet, W. H. Auden is trying to describe in his book, The Enchafed Flood, a study of the iconography of the sea, when he refers to the sea as "that state of barbaric vagueness and disorder out of which civilization has emerged." Literary treatments of the sea voyage, he continues, are often quests for possibility, away from the land-locked world hopelessly bound by necessity. Here Auden identifies those elemental pulses in all of us, because the sea is in us. As Rachel Carson once noted, human blood contains sodium, potassium, and calcium almost in the same proportion as sea water.
We came from the sea and, in some respect, we all continue to feel the call of the sea, a summons to explore life's conditions and challenges, its tragedies and triumphs. In another of Longfellow's poems called "The Secrets of the Sea," the poem's speaker recalls the experience of a landsman who asks an ancient helmsman to teach him the "wondrous song" he sings. The helmsman, whose song is about the secrets of the sea, replies, "Only those who brave its dangers / Comprehend its mystery!" Melville and Longfellow, Thoreau and Poe, Whitman and Dickinson, braved its dangers, because they wanted to comprehend its mystery. The question remains, why didn't Hawthorne? The question becomes more compelling when you consider the fact that, like his contemporaries, and perhaps even moreso than any of them, Hawthorne recognized consistently and profoundly the symbolic potential fo virtually every object he placed in his literary productions. If you're familiar with The House of the Seven Gables, you know how susceptible Hawthorne's imagination was to playing over the meanings behind things and eliciting powerful associations from those meanings. Think, for example, of the house itself, the elm tree, the cent shop, the antique oaken chair, the well, the chickens, Alice's poesies, Hepzibah's gloves, the harpsichord, the organ-grinder, the portrait of Colonel Pyncheon, the miniature of Clifford, Judge Pyncheon's gold-headed can, and the railroad in that work. Also, like his contemporaries, Hawthorne was interested in exploring the journey-of-life archetype, and does so in at least a dozen of his shorter works and in most of his romances. But all of these journeys take place on land.
It seems curious that a man who lived by the sea, worked in sea-related occupations, enjoyed walking by the sea, had close friends who wrote about the sea, and whose writings are replete with symbolic journeys should not have composed any stories of the sea. This is not to say that there are no references to the sea in his works, but in the few places where they do occur, they are usually not central to the work's chief interest, as in the tales, "Drowne's Wooden Image" and "Night Sketches."
In perhaps his most sustained description of the sea, a little-known sketch called "Footprints by the Sea-shore," Hawthorne portrays his own fondness for long walks along the seashore in the figure of a young man strolling along a beach (probably the Swampscott-Lynn seashore), in search of solitude, a search, he says, that invariably draws him to the sea. The lighter side of this sketch is the appearance and reappearance three more times of three young women who flirt with him from a distance and, despite his desire for seclusion, he flirts back. Between these encounters, he muses on beach birds, on the shore's rocky outline, and on the flotsam and jetsam found along the shore. Having felt the summons of the sea, he has gone, but his presence there is not without some sources of anxiety, even though the sea is calm. On one occasion, he is struck by "an... overpowering conception of the majesty and awfulness of the sea." Immediately after that, he muses over the transience of life as he considers writing his name in the sand. On another occasion, he imagines the sunken ships and corpses of the ocean in a tidal basin. A few moments later, the melancholy voice of the sea speaks of the location of sunken ships and warns the listener to "let the infinite idea of eternity pervade his soul." As evening approaches, fretful of the prospect of being haunted by "gloomy fantasies," he retreats from the saddened tones of the surf back to humans, presumably for a feast of fish and chowder with the young girls. There is a delicate balance in this sketch between its playfulness and its sources of tension, most of which emanate from associations of death with the sea. In a recent biography of Hawthorne, Edwin Miller proposes as his central thesis, in his portrait of the man and the writer, that the death of Hawthorne's father during a sea voyage when Hawthorne was just four years old was the central trauma that precipitated a search by Hawthorne throughout his adult life, and through his fiction, for the lost father. Miller's autobiography has its detractors, especially those who prefer to see a relatively well-adjusted, modestly happy, and eminently successful author. But I think Miller recognized a central fact in the psychic life of this author. In another Hawthorne story called "The Wives of the Dead," two young women are grieving over the recent deaths of their husbands who were brothers. One, a landsman, was killed in a battle; the other, a sailor, drowned at sea. One night, while the sailor's wife, Mary, is asleep, a visitor arrives to tell Margaret, the landsman's wife, that her husband is alive, after all, and on his way home. Overcome with joy at the news, Margaret thinks of waking Mary to tell her of her good fortune, but decides, under the circumstances, that it would deepen Mary's own grief, so she goes to bed. A short time later, Mary appears to awaken, hears a knock at the door, and answers it. A sailor tells her that her husband had clung to a spar after his ship was wrecked, had been rescued and was on his way home. Mary now considers sharing her good news with Margaret but decides not to, for the same reasons Margaret did. The story ends with the following sentences: "Before retiring, she /Mary/... endeavored to arrange the bed-clothes, so that the chill air might not do harm to the feverish slumberer /Margaret/. But her hand trembled against Margaret's neck, a tear also fell upon her cheek, and she suddenly awoke." The last three words are intriguingly ambiguous. We are led to ask, "Who suddenly awoke?" If Margaret, then the two brothers are alive and well. But if Mary, then the entire scene is a dream, a fantasy of wish fulfillment in the unconscious world of sleep, by which the grieving wife of the sailor is able to bring back the dead huband from the sea. That the dream is by the wife rather than the son of the missing sailor doesn't diminish the powerful emotions being expressed here. It is not uncommon for humans to project their feelings on others when the feelings are too painful to bear.
In any event, the image of the grieving wife was certainly one Hawthorne was familiar with, and his own psychic pain might have been intensified by the pathetic figure of his mother, dressed in black for the rest of her forty or so years of life, and rarely coming out of her room during that period, even for meals. In another of Hawthorne's lesser-known sketches called "Chippings With a Chisel," Hawthorne appears to attempt to provide a rationale for his mother's behavior, in the portrait of an elderly lady who visits a tombstone carver one day to request that he fashion a monument for her first love, who had been killed by a whale forty years earlier. The narrator observes, "It was singular that so strong an early impression of feeling should have survived through the changes of her subsequent life, in the course of which she had been a wife and mother... Reflecting within myself, it appeared to me that this life-long sorrow... was one of the most fortunate circumstances of her history. It had given an ideality to her mind; it had kept her purer and less earthly than she would otherwise have been." This is a remarkably sympathetic portrait by a son who must have felt, on some occasions, abandoned not only by his father but also his mother. But it may be more revealing if read as an unconscious self portrait.
In August of 1852, Herman Melville heard a story while visiting Nantucket of a Quaker woman named Agatha Robertson whose sailor husband had abandoned her after two years of marriage, only to return seventeen years later, offering her financial help without revealing a second marriage. Melville saw the possibilities of a story here, and sketched them out in a letter to Hawthorne, inviting Hawthorne to write the story. Any number of circumstances may have contributed to Hawthorne's unwillingness to do so, including the distractions of Pierce's campaign for the presidency and Hawthorne's preoccupation with the spoils that would come from Pierce's election. But I think that this was one of those occasions when a potential story of the sea presented itself to Hawthorne with all the baggage of his own unresolved conflicts about a subject that was too painful to touch.
A haunting image relevant to his subject appears in The Scarlet Letter. After being released from jail, Hester takes up residence with her daughter, Pearl, in a solitary cottage by the seashore. There they live for the next seven years, isolated from the rest of the community--the child without a father, the woman a virtual widow. In this portrait of a child who searches for her father and a woman abandoned by both her husband and her lover, we have Hawthorne's own version of the Agatha story, conceived from the deepest part of his emotional life, shortly after the death of his mother, and well before he heard it from Melville. It is the closest he would come to writing it. In Hawthorne's version of the stroy, the child eventually escapes across the sea to a life of security, prosperity, and happiness. Perhaps this was Hawthorne's romance of the sea.

Related Readings
Albion, Robert G., William A. Baker, and Benjamin J. Labaree
(1972). "The Golden Age, 1815-1865," in New England and the Sea. Mystic, Connecticut: Mystic Seaport Museum.

Bridge, Horatio (1893). Personal Recollections of Nathaniel
Hawthorne. New York: Harper.

Erlich, Gloria C. (1984). Family Themes and Hawthorne's Fiction:
The Tenacious Web. New Brunswick: Rutgers.

Herbert, T. Walter (1993). Dearest Beloved: The Hawthornes and
the Making of the Middle-Class Family. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Mellow, James R. (1980). Nathaniel Hawthorne in His Times.
Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

Miller, Edwin Haviland (1991). Salem Is My Dwelling Place: A Life of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press.

Salem National Maritime Historic Site (1987). Maritime Salem in
the Age of Sail. Handbook 126. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department. of the Interior.

Turner, Arlin (1980). Nathaniel Hawthorne: A Biography. New York
& Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Von Saltza's Paintings used to illustrate essay

1. Engagement of the Brig Grand Turk of Salem and the British Brig Hinehinbroke May 1814.

2. Bark Richard of Salem passing Baker's Is. outward bound for Rio de Janeiro 1827.

3. Crowninshield's Wharf Salem 1806

4. Ship Glide of Salem entering Bay of Islands New Zealand Sept 1829 greeted by Maoris.

5. Ship Hercules of Salem passing the Mole Head of Naples coming to anchor September 1809.

6. Ship Belisarius Robert Peele Master leaving Salem April 1st 1805



Joseph Flibbert is a Professor in the English Department at Salem State. The author of a book on Herman Melville, his current research interests focus on Nathaniel Hawthorne. He contributed a chapter on nineteenth-century American sea poetry to the forthcoming book, America and the Sea: A Literary History.


Back to Volume 5, no. 1 Index